GILD analysis
Devin Desktop (formerly Windsurf) Review
Pick Devin Desktop when engineers will move into one editor that runs Devin Local, third-party ACP agents, and Devin cloud sessions, tracked in one Agent Command Center. Devin Local has replaced Cascade, so rewrite any Windsurf rollout plan. Admins enforce permission rules and MCP and model allowlists, and SSO and role-based access require Enterprise.
- AI Coding Agents
- Engineering Productivity
The decision
- Best fit
- Teams that want to run several coding agents from one editor, with admin-enforced permissions.
- Consider another workflow
- If engineers want to keep their current editors, an extension or terminal agent avoids the switch; the Windsurf JetBrains plugin is in maintenance mode.
- Adoption condition
- Team permission rules, an MCP allowlist, spending limits, and human review before merge.